ERP for Manufacturing Industry

We are independent ERP consultants specializing in ERP for manufacturing industry, from software selection through to implementation. We do not accept compensation from any vendor or implementer, so our advice is entirely in your interest.

Manufacturing ERP Software Comparison

Compare Manufacturing ERP software by scrolling down and across to see their applications/modules, number of customers, underlying technology and critical generic requirements.

Click to filter by Tier, System, Application, Industry, Criteria Category and Criteria Detail.
Tier
System
Compare Criteria
Product Information
System
Vendor
Description
Website
Primary Tier
Industries
Applications
Developer Information
Number of customers - all products
Number of customers - this product
Technology
% of application that is web based (just need a browser on workstation)
On premise, cloud or hybrid
Private or Public Cloud
Tenant Architecture
Generic Requirements
Customization/Configuration
Without changing source code
User-defined fields
  • Can define values/dropdowns for fields
  • Used in report selection and ordering
  • Used in workflow
User defined screens
  • Change fields to required, optional or invisible for standard and user-defined field
Multiple Companies
Share inventory across companies
Share customers and suppliers across companies
Automate balancing of transactions across legal entities
PO of 1 company automatically generates the sales order in another company
Multiple Currencies
Maintain source and home currency amount for each transaction
Date effective currency exchange rates
Work Flow
Can apply an approval process to any transaction such as a journal entry or any master file such as a supplier or inventory item
Can generate alerts/escalation if something expected is late or reminders
Configurable approvals or alerts without needing programming
Mobility
Optimized for Android and iPhone
Offline mode and synch when internet connected
Sales tax compliance
Canadian sales tax compliance
US sales tax compliance
Reporting/Business Intelligence
Reporting
Industry standard reporting tool and can change existing reports or add new ones
Ad-hoc reporting (don’t need a programmer) with filtering, sorting and summarizing options
Dashboards
Based on real time updates from all transactions
Role specific
Configurable dashboards - don't need to be a programmer to create or change dashboard
Analytics
Drag and drop dimensions
Visualization/graphic representation of data

Not all manufacturing ERP software are created equal. There is a big variance in functionality for a specific industry and for the size of company. Small companies don’t need the complexity required for larger companies. There is also a big difference in the ERP vendors which can be:

  • Vendors with solutions for multiple industries. These systems are more complicated to setup because of all the industries they support.
  • Vendors that offer a solution for a specific industry.
  • Vendors that offer an extension developed by a 3rd party for a specific industry.
This page covers unique ERP requirements for manufacturing industry, an manufacturing ERP system comparison across leading systems, and the ERP implementers that specialize in this space. If you would like independent guidance on which direction is right for your company, we would be glad to help.
Manufacturing ERP Software | Manufacturing Services ERP Systems Comparision

ERP Implementers for Manufacturing Industry

180 Systems conduct dozens of ERP selections every year. With our deep knowledge of ERP for manufacturing industry, we will help you find the right ERP system for your company and the right professional services company to implement it.
Manufacturing ERP Software | Manufacturing Services ERP Systems Comparision

Designed for 1 or more of the following industry types:

+ Process (EG food)
+ Repetitive (EG consumer electronics)
+
Make to Stock (EG consumer household goods)
+
Assemble to Order (EG personal computers)
+
Make to Order (EG complex custom products)
+
Engineer to Order (EG ship building)

Setup

+ Multi-level bill of materials
+ Bill of operations with the steps to make a product or subassembly
+ Routings with capacity, multiple dependency types and could include subcontractors

Scheduling

+ Finite scheduling based on labour and equipment constraints
+ By department or routing
+ Minimize setup time
+ Drag and drop schedule changes

Shop Floor Control

+ Generate work orders
+ Scanning used for all inventory movements
+ RFID support
+ Automated data collection for labour and materials
+ Scanning and backflushing used to consume inventory
+ PLC integration

Other

+ Integrated QC
+ MRP
+ Configurator for custom (make to order and engineer to order) products

ERP Implementers for Manufacturing Industry

180 Systems conduct dozens of ERP selections every year. With our deep knowledge of ERP for manufacturing industry, we will help you find the right ERP system for your company and the right professional services company to implement it.

Why You Should Hire 180 Systems as Your Manufacturing ERP Software Consultant

180 Systems Differentiators

1. Independence

We are independent ERP consultants and do not accept any compensation from vendors or implementers.

2. Requirements Analysis

Our analysis is mostly based on business process reviews rather than generic requirements checklists.

3. Strategic alignment

We identify requirements to attain critical success factors (CSFs) and use KPI’s to measure attainment of CSF’s as objectives for an ERP implementation.

4. Manufacturing ERP Experience

We have extensive experience in Manufacturing ERP software selection and implementation with testimonials below.

5. Methodology

We have a documented best practice methodology with numerous proven templates to manage ERP selections and implementations.

6. Efficient

We don’t waste anyone’s time. For example, ERP vendors are asked to only respond to critical requirements in an RFP with the goal of 20% of requirements deemed critical.

7. Cost

Our fees are low because we have little overhead, and don’t exceed a maximum unless there is a change in scope and it has been approved.

8. Trusted Advisors

Our clients know that we will always act with integrity and honesty.

Resources for Manufacturing Industry ERP Selection and Implementation

180-Systems_ERP-Software-Implementers-Selection-Tool

ERP Software & Implementers Selection Tool

You can filter ERP software by application, tier, and industry...

180-Systems_System-Selection-Methodology

System Selection Methodology

This is a ERP software selection process that you are probably dreading ...

180-Systems-_-ERP-Software-Implementers-Selection-Tool

ERP Total Cost of Ownership

When considering the total ERP software cost, it’s not just license fees and...

Testimonial

From clients we’ve helped with Manufacturing ERP Software selection and/or implementation

We had received a government grant for a system selection project for a new ERP system, which required us to hire outside consultants for the evaluation. We engaged 180 Systems, and it was probably the best thing that could happen to us. They made us step back and took us through a very detailed process of how we evaluate the suppliers, and we wouldn’t have been nearly as thorough without them. They helped with identifying needs, putting out proposals, and evaluating the suppliers. With their detailed selection process, they found the right fit for us as a supplier and also a solution that fit within our budget. Alex was great, very thorough and helpful as were the other 180 consultants.
Dan Nussbaum, PresidentArconas Corp
We chose 180 Systems as they were highly recommended. They had good people, highly experienced, and they had worked with the partner in the past, so they topped the list and we engaged them. They provided us great support. Michael, helping us with negotiating the contract, I can tell you without him we wouldn’t have got through so quickly, and at the same time we got what we wanted. On implementation, Alex came in and managed the project and implementation, including complicated things we didn’t see at the beginning. Without 180 Systems, we would have blown the budget and not have what we wanted. Our experience was very very good, and we are looking forward to working with them again.
Adam Esat, Director of FinanceCrystal Fountains
The project was successful, and while we have strong internal experience with ERP implementations, what was essential this time was having dedicated, external project management. In previous implementations, we were able to free up internal resources, but given the scale of this project and competing priorities, that wasn’t possible here.
Having Alex and Nelofer from 180 Systems fully focused on project governance, tracking all action items, ensuring follow-through, managing dependencies, and reinforcing decisions made a significant difference. Even with prior Kinetic experience, the complexity of a project of this size benefits greatly from an external team that brings structure, discipline, and focus.
180 Systems is highly project-oriented, with strong tools and a very pragmatic approach. They were instrumental in keeping the project on track and ensuring a successful implementation. We would absolutely engage them again for future initiatives.
Luce Lavoie, Vice President, Financial & Business AnalysisPattison ID
Our experience with 180 Systems was excellent. Unlike many consultants, their work was practical, insightful and value driven. The support they provided, from system selection through implementation, was a wise investment and allowed us to free up significant internal resources. Overall, we are very pleased with the professionalism, expertise, and quality of service that they delivered.
Nick Zhang, Director of FinanceProgress Luv2Pak
180 Systems are very knowledgeable, know what they are talking about and able to bring their expertise to marry all the information in a format that everyone could understand. Besides technical knowledge and experience, they also understand the business flows and business issues which generated many conversations on both the technical and business sides which we appreciated the value that they had brought to our business challenges. They were also able to effectively communicate and bring everyone onside.
Darcy Raun, Chief Financial OfficerEdmonton Exchanger
Michael is an expert in the subject matter, he understood our process and was able to adapt to our situation.  He was analytical, detailed, did a nice job of herding cats which is a big part of the project. I think he was comprehensive, very systematic.  He didn’t ever overlook anything, and had a nice balance of what was important and what was not important to us.  He was a good fit for what we needed, a catalyst for the process, making it all happen. He helped keep our energy level up, just pushing us forward in a very professional and organized fashion.
Paul Liljegren, Vice President & Corporate Controller Kissner Group
Michael was able to take what our people were saying and boil it down to exactly what was needed and how the system needed to work. We sent that out to eight or nine vendors, and when they responded, he was able to rate them on a scale of one to ten in terms of meeting our requirements, and also what customization would be required. These are all things he has done over and over again, but for us the process was perfect. He doesn't operate from a certain bias, he tries to steer you. So he did a wonderful job.
Paul Santin, VP Finance & AdministrationBrenlo Ltd. Custom Wood Mouldings
At the time, Railtech was looking to replace their existing system, and didn't have the expertise internally. We did some research, but were not making much progress. We asked our auditors for advice, but felt they were trying to fit them into the systems they already knew. Then I saw Michael mentioned in the CA Magazine, an independent consultant who knew the industry, so we decided to start a dialogue. We were looking for someone independent, who had knowledge of the different systems available, and that's what we got with Michael. In terms of Michael's approach, our group found him to be very organized, methodical, and very knowledgeable about the various systems. We were happy with the overall process and results. In hindsight, it might have been helpful to involve 180 Systems during the implementation phase, for advice and oversight.
Jess Fagnani, Vice President - FinanceRailtech Ltd.
We were very impressed with Michael and the work done by 180 Systems. We looked to an outside source to assist us with the system selection process as we did not have much experience with this in house. Michael is very knowledgeable in the field, and his multi-faceted approach to the RFP process is well thought out. Services were provided in an objective, professional manner. In addition, the consulting fees were reasonable. I would unequivocally recommend the services of 180 Systems.
Kevin Semenjuk, Project ManagerEdmonton Exchanger Group of Companies
180 Systems was good, kept us in line, and really knew what they were talking about, which was evident right away - that was very helpful for us. The best thing about 180 Systems is that everybody who dealt with them was quite impressed with their background. They have their tool chest, forms and processes, and pulled them out and got right down to work. It surprised us at some of the stuff they were able to do.
Ryan Kolynchuk, Finance & Administration ManagerJRS MFG. LTD.
I am happy with 180 Systems' work and generally thought it was very good. I liked the approach, the pricing was reasonable and their use of time was well managed. We considered using a larger consulting company, but ruled them out as they were considered not as cost effective as 180 Systems.
Brad Narfason , PresidentGKD Industries Ltd.

Frequently Asked Questions: ERP for Manufacturing Industry

What is manufacturing ERP and why do manufacturers need a specialized system?

ERP manufacturing is an enterprise resource planning system built or configured to manage the specific operational requirements of manufacturing businesses. Unlike generic ERP systems, manufacturing ERP software supports production scheduling, shop floor control, bill of materials, material requirements planning (MRP), quality control, and capacity planning in a single integrated platform. The right system depends heavily on your manufacturing model, whether you operate process, repetitive, make to stock, assemble to order, make to order, or engineer to order production, as requirements differ significantly across these types.

What are the key ERP requirements for manufacturers?

ERP for manufacturers must handle multi-level bill of materials, bill of operations, routings with capacity and dependency management, finite scheduling based on labour and equipment constraints, shop floor control including work order generation and inventory scanning, MRP, integrated quality control, and configurator support for make to order and engineer to order environments. The complexity of these requirements means that selecting the wrong system, or a system that requires heavy customization to support your production model, is one of the most common and costly mistakes manufacturers make.

How do I choose the right ERP software for manufacturing industry operations?

Start with a thorough requirements analysis based on your specific production model and business processes, not a generic checklist. From there, evaluate systems across Tier 1, Tier 2, and Tier 3 options to find the right fit for your company size and complexity. The manufacturing ERP software comparison table on this page covers over 30 systems across all tiers. Independent ERP consultants can help you run a structured vendor evaluation, manage the RFP process, and negotiate your contract without any vendor bias.

How much does manufacturing ERP software cost?

ERP costs for manufacturers vary significantly depending on the tier of system, number of users, complexity of production requirements, and deployment model. Process manufacturers and engineer to order manufacturers typically face higher implementation costs than make to stock operations due to the complexity of formula management, configurators, and custom scheduling requirements. For a realistic breakdown of what to budget for, read our article on ERP Total Cost of Ownership.

Why should manufacturers use independent ERP consultants rather than going directly to a vendor?

ERP vendors and their implementation partners are motivated to sell their own solution. Independent ERP consultants like 180 Systems do not accept compensation from any vendor or implementer, so the recommendation you receive is based entirely on your production requirements. This matters especially in manufacturing, where vendors frequently position their system as capable of handling your specific production model when in practice significant customization is required. As one of our manufacturing clients noted, having an independent consultant meant they found the right fit within their budget, something they would not have achieved going directly to vendors.

Does 180 Systems have experience with manufacturing ERP selection and implementation?

Yes. 180 Systems has helped manufacturers across Canada select and implement ERP systems across a wide range of production environments, including discrete manufacturing, process manufacturing, make to order, and engineer to order operations. Clients include Arconas Corp, Crystal Fountains, Pattison ID, Edmonton Exchanger, Kissner Group, Railtech, and Brenlo, among others. Our consultants have deep knowledge of manufacturing ERP software for the industry and bring a structured, methodology-driven approach to every selection and implementation project. See our Client’s Testimonials https://180systems.kinex12.com/about-us/testimonials/.

Help is just a click away

Contact us for independent advice on whether and how to replace or optimize your ERP software for manufacturing industry.